| | Results 1° round (06/02) |  |
|
+14GloryQuestor maijinto_larryk Autraya Flo' raizen hiru la_caroline .Nero. Nya-chan Production Koys osnar Dn@ JunJun simofc90 18 posters |
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
simofc90
Number of posts : 34
Registration date : 2009-02-03
 |  Subject: Results 1° round (06/02)  Fri 13 Feb - 21:11 | |
|
Last edited by simofc90 on Fri 13 Feb - 22:58; edited 2 times in total | |
|
 | |
JunJun
Number of posts : 47
Age : 36
Localisation : Somewhere in Hueco Mundo, playing with Szayel's dolls.
Registration date : 2009-02-06
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:14 | |
| - simofc90 wrote:
- joking :>
You're amusing like a tour in Hell. : | | |
|
| | |
Dn@
Number of posts : 109
Age : 36
Localisation : Paris O:
Registration date : 2009-02-03
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:15 | |
| | |
|
| | |
osnar
Number of posts : 46
Registration date : 2009-02-05
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:21 | |
| | |
|
| | |
Invité
Guest
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:24 | |
| Woo, first place video owned the hell outta me....loved all those blurs
Last edited by Reda on Fri 13 Feb - 21:41; edited 1 time in total |
|
| | |
Koys
Number of posts : 19
Age : 33
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:25 | |
| GG mina,good job juge  | |
|
| | |
Nya-chan Production
Number of posts : 86
Age : 37
Localisation : Atashi no... yume...
Registration date : 2009-02-05
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:38 | |
| | |
|
| | |
.Nero.
Number of posts : 10
Age : 30
Localisation : rome
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:40 | |
| | |
|
| | |
la_caroline
Number of posts : 3
Registration date : 2009-02-08
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:47 | |
| | |
|
| | |
hiru
Number of posts : 39
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 21:55 | |
| Larryck Putin !!  | |
|
| | |
JunJun
Number of posts : 47
Age : 36
Localisation : Somewhere in Hueco Mundo, playing with Szayel's dolls.
Registration date : 2009-02-06
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 22:00 | |
| ...still can't believe it. ò__o | |
|
| | |
Dn@
Number of posts : 109
Age : 36
Localisation : Paris O:
Registration date : 2009-02-03
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 22:11 | |
| Here is my ranking for each groups + comments. - Spoiler:
Group 1:
1st- Voices
+ Storyline/Coherence
+ Anime choice
+ Video quality
+ Editing
- In my opinion none it's a pretty hawt ic
2nd- WEST_Round1_Shizzles
+ Coherence
+ Anime Choice
+ Great finish
+ Nice gestion of music variation
- Some scene selection
It was very difficult for me to tell which amv was 3rd and 4th of this group in my ranking but i've made my choice ^^"
3rd- LUTV_round1
+ Scene selection
+ Video quality
+ Editing Ideas
- Some effects
- Synch at some parts
4th- T.A_IC_round1
+ Concept
+ Ideas
+ Synch
+ 2nd part of the music
- Way to illustrate ideas
- Some rough transition that diden't fit with music mostly in the begining
- Scene selection in begining
- Video quality not so good for HD
Group 2:
1st- Winner_of_Round_1
+ Lyrich synch
+ Coherence
+ Editing
- Synch and music variations
2nd-Pulse_Round1
+ Editing Ideas
+ The editor took some risks and spend some time in it
+ Synch
- Draft effects sometimes like chroma
- Useless Masks
- Video quality (source is HD or FHD)
3rd-Magic_IC_round1
+ Editing ideas
+ Coherence
- Synch
- Video quality
- Music variation
4th-IC 1 round 2g
+ Some good transitions and ideas
- Video quality
- Anime and scene selection
- Editing in general diden't fit the song at all
Group 3:
1st-KNK_ICVID_Round1
+ Anime & Scene selection
+ Lyric synchs
+ Synch and music variation
+ Video quality
+ Editing in general
- Characters speaks when not needed
- Synch some time could have been better but it's still a pretty good ic
2nd- FSN_IC_round1
+ Scene selection
+ Synch
+ Editing ideas
+ some effects like red color and noise well placed
- Black fades and sometimes too many cuts
- Scene selection at some places
I wasen't sure about puting this one (gothica) 3rd or 4th.
3rd- GothicA
+ Mood of the video fits great to the song
+ Editing ideas
+ Scene selections
+ Awsm finish sequence
- Synch big variations of music aren't marked well enough
- Interlaced source & Black borders
- Lip synch
- Begining of the music
4th- Through the Geassb
+ Begining
+ Good editing ideas
+ Synch
+ Video quality
- Scene selection
- Useless color effects that diden't fit the video & music
- Lyrich synch seems off to me
- Coherence
5th- [WEST IC 1st Round] Profane Love
+ Ideas
+ Some scene selection
- Editing
- Synch
- Lots of other things ^^"
Group 4:
1st-- Ah_group4_I am a killer but please love me
+ Coherence/Lyrich synch
+ Best begining
+ Editing
+ Scene selection & story
- 2nd part of the amv wasen't edit as good as begining
- Video quality
2nd- passion_round1
+ Best editing through the all amv
+ Synch
+ Scene Selection
- Lyrich synch
- Anime
3rd- Pale_cocoon_IC
4th- DuelingGhosts
5th- ParadoxicalDream_group4.XviD[/b]
Group 5:
I hesitate puting this one 1st or 2nd i choosed the video with the most constant editing
1st- Fight The Powa!
+synch
+choice of anime
+ constant editing
- video quality and black borders
- Some accelerations
2nd- ADC_IC_round1
+ Best begining with the song
+ video quality
+ Editing ideas and effects
- End of the song not well edited seems like the editor diden't work enough this part
- Synch
I hesitate puting this one 3rd or 4th but the defalts in the amv=D were bigger
3rd- aut_has_small_penis
+ Anime choice
+ Video quality
+ Finishing scene
+ the 2nd half
- 1st half
- Synch
- Music variations
4th- AMV=D
+ Synch
+ Good editing ideas
- Bad realisation of his ideas
- Very draft effects like the blood that isen't well incrusted in the video
- Encode is horrible (black borders interlaced)
- Too many flashes and superposition most of the time unjustified
- Coherence
| |
|
| | |
hiru
Number of posts : 39
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 22:31 | |
| JuJun !!! Verry Nice Clipe !!  | |
|
| | |
raizen
Number of posts : 2
Registration date : 2009-02-13
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Fri 13 Feb - 22:43 | |
| | |
|
| | |
Flo'
Number of posts : 5
Age : 31
Registration date : 2009-02-05
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 0:10 | |
| Omg I'm 1 XD I have the power  | |
|
| | |
JunJun
Number of posts : 47
Age : 36
Localisation : Somewhere in Hueco Mundo, playing with Szayel's dolls.
Registration date : 2009-02-06
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 0:33 | |
| - Flo' wrote:
- Omg I'm 1 XD
I have the power Indeed. XD - hiru wrote:
- JuJun !!! Verry Nice Clipe !!
Thanks ^*^ | |
|
| | |
Autraya
Number of posts : 64
Localisation : Australia
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 1:04 | |
| My vote for best videos including comments, don't cry like big babies because i was mean  Group 1:- Spoiler:
1. Voices_IC_1round.mp4
comment: this is how this song is meant to be edited!!
2. WEST_Round1_Shizzles.mp4
comment: some editing is a bit rough but picks up well near the end, i was very bored tho
3. TA_IC)round1.avi
comment: note the sync in this was pretty much the same as the last video (girl who leapt through time) BUT this one has a much better story and isn't using boring effects, also the way it used 2 anime to tell the story was a good idea but not so good to work out, so i voted for this one :p
4. LUTC|V.mp4
comment: sync is not so good, story is not so good just had not much going for it.
Group 2:- Spoiler:
1. Winner_of_round1.mp4
comments: I am SO sick of this source BUT this was the best edited video in this group.
2. Pulse_Round1.mp4
comments: yet again sick of source, black flashes were horrid, spent more time to edit this though and did a few effects, the rest is just shiney footage, i will not be fooled by shiney
3. IC_1_round_2g.mp4
comment: this video has sections with bad editing, it is not cleaned very well at all, but i pick this over the Magic_IC because it has more depth and the editor tried to make something different not just boring drama like all the others.
4. Magic_IC
comment: The editing in Magic_IC is better than IC_1_round_2g.mp4 but i had more fun watching the other video, this was still a pretty good video.
Group 3:- Spoiler:
1. KNK_ICVID_Round1
comment: nice consistent editing, well picked anime & scenes, changes when it needs to but nothing really jumps out at me.
2. GothicA
comments: begining has a nice contrast to the rest, just too many shots of her face at points in the fchorus but also syncs where it's supposed too.
3. Through the GeasB
comment: I prefer the editing in this to the FSN video and it tries to tell a story, but I am disapointed with using code geas there is much more and better footage that could be used, once again i like the contrast in hte begining, the geas affecting mind blue strand stuff it used waaay too much though so i almost picked FSN.
4. FSN_IC.mp4
comment: the sync in the begining of this was all over the place, pick a style and set of beats and stick with it, the ending was also anticlimactic and for all the great footage in FSN i was pretty disapointed with what was chosen for this video, if there was a story here i did not follow it.
5. Profane_love.mp4
comment: ok i'm trying not to be mean but this video just plain sucks, sync, black flashes, black borders, editing/transitions/scene selection, picture quality, mood everything. The anime could have worked, it was a fantastic combo that really could have kicked arse... but really didn't. I suppose this one annoys me because there are moments when i see the video it could have been x_x
Group 4:- Spoiler:
1. Ah_I'm A killer but please love me.mp4
comment: In the middle this is not so good but i love the story and gets much better at the end, nice IC vid :3
2. Passion_round1.avi
comment: this video i had the most trouble dloading, I like the skip and jump of scenes to hit the beat, feels dfferent but works well for this song, but the anime did not fit so well.
3. Paradoxical dream.avi
comment: there was not much difference between this and the other remaining editing on this was better for the beat BUT it has major techinical issues, all of the AR is wrong and interlacing, but i voted for this over pale cocoon because it is more consistent all the way through.
4. Pale_cocoon.avi
comment: the flow in this video was terible, fast then slow then fast then arrgh, this was just not a good anime for a dance song to limited for footage. Visual quality is nice and proper AR though
5. Dueling ghosts.avi
comment: I love the idea of combining GITS, GITS innocence & GITS TV, BUT most of the sync was accidental and quality was not so good.
Group 5:- Spoiler:
1. amv_D.avi
comment: great consistant editing, the splater was a bit lame but fitting.... PLEASE DEINTERLACE YOUR SOURCE NEXT TIME!!!!
2. Fight_da_powa!.avi
Comment: great feel to this captured the feel of the music best out of all! some weak spots with editing but about 80% was great
3. Aut_has_small_penis.mp4
comment: I vote this for best video name, the begining is jusr plain lazy and sync/feel of the music just doesn't work together after about 1/2 way through the editing fits better and is slick.....kazzam
4. ADC_IC.mp4
Comment: About the last video FFAC, I lol'd and thought "they have it made this is gonna kick arse"- it has the BEST intro for the song but then just falls apart T_T if only it had been kept up then it would have been a much harder choice and I'm not sure who i would have picked
| |
|
| | |
maijinto_larryk
Number of posts : 13
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 1:26 | |
| | |
|
| | |
Nya-chan Production
Number of posts : 86
Age : 37
Localisation : Atashi no... yume...
Registration date : 2009-02-05
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 1:32 | |
| - Autraya wrote:
- Spoiler:
1. Winner_of_round1.mp4
comments: I am SO sick of this source BUT this was the best edited video in this group.
Beyond the Clouds, 5cm or Shinkai in general?  | |
|
| | |
simofc90
Number of posts : 34
Registration date : 2009-02-03
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 2:35 | |
| I think she means overused stuff | |
|
| | |
Nya-chan Production
Number of posts : 86
Age : 37
Localisation : Atashi no... yume...
Registration date : 2009-02-05
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 3:03 | |
| - simofc90 wrote:
- I think she means overused stuff
And I am asking what exactly she means, since I used two sources ^^ | |
|
| | |
GloryQuestor
Number of posts : 9
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 3:28 | |
| Ah, well. It was still fun.  Thanks for the invite and good luck to the rest of the contestants. (And, Autraya, just a question ... does "accidental sync" mean "internal sync"? Because, afaik, internal sync with a song actually isn't supposed to be a negative aspect... just curious.  ) | |
|
| | |
Nya-chan Production
Number of posts : 86
Age : 37
Localisation : Atashi no... yume...
Registration date : 2009-02-05
| |
| | |
Autraya
Number of posts : 64
Localisation : Australia
Registration date : 2009-02-04
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 7:04 | |
| - Nya-chan Production wrote:
- simofc90 wrote:
- I think she means overused stuff
And I am asking what exactly she means, since I used two sources ^^ Simo is correct. To expand on it for you tho -the whole suite of movies 5cm, place beyond the cloud, promised in our early days etc blah blah... i wholly subscribe to Crack the sky's ZOMG WOW sig. My problem with them besides being overused is that they are all used in the same way "yet another drama vid" similar to "yet another dbz/naruto/FFAC fighting vid" x_x But as you see my personal dislike(or like) of the source has no bearing on judging, if it's well edited and fits to the song it'll do just as well as a video with a source that i like.  G_Q: what i noticed happening in the vid a lot was several gunshots were synced and the gun shots continued and weren't, so it looks like some bits were meant to sync and then others just didn't, there's some fighting behind pillars in the movie and some parts sync yet the next part of the scene didn't. So it looks "accidental" /me hopes that helps, needed more transitions as a whole, btw i was wondering what was up with the eye colour change sneaky masking :p iIf other people have questions about the comments I made feel free to ask, none of them should be taken personally as they are just my notes/explanations to the other judges as to what i was thinking when i rated the videos. I actually had no idea who edited any videos.... although i should have guessed about the penis one  | |
|
| | |
Woy
Number of posts : 3
Registration date : 2009-02-05
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) Sat 14 Feb - 14:39 | |
| First, congrats to all of you... for all the AMVs I'm downloading right now... and sorry for the ones who lost, but  | |
|
| | |
Sponsored content
| | Subject: Re: Results 1° round (06/02) | |
| |
|
| | |
| | Results 1° round (06/02) | |
|
